The Two Great Retreats of History by George Grote and comte de Philippe-Paul Ségur

(2 User reviews)   754
By Dylan Martin Posted on Mar 18, 2026
In Category - The Deep Shelf
Ségur, Philippe-Paul, comte de, 1780-1873 Ségur, Philippe-Paul, comte de, 1780-1873
English
Hey, have you ever wondered what it actually felt like to be part of Napoleon's army as it completely fell apart? Not the grand strategy you read in textbooks, but the day-to-day reality of freezing, starving men trying to survive a retreat that became a legend? I just finished a book that gives you exactly that front-row seat. It’s called 'The Two Great Retreats of History,' and it pairs two epic disasters: the Greek Ten Thousand’s march home after a failed coup in Persia, and Napoleon’s catastrophic retreat from Moscow in 1812. The second half, written by Count Philippe-Paul de Ségur, is the real showstopper. He was there, as one of Napoleon’s own aides-de-camp. He doesn’t just tell you the army froze; he makes you feel the cold creeping into your bones and the desperation of watching an invincible force disintegrate into a starving mob. It’s less a dry history and more a brutal, personal survival story on a massive scale. If you think you know the story of 1812, this account from inside the collapse will change your perspective completely.
Share

This book is actually a two-for-one historical package. The first part, by George Grote, covers the ancient 'Retreat of the Ten Thousand' Greeks from Persia in 401 BC, a story of disciplined soldiers fighting their way home against all odds. It's a classic tale of endurance. But the heart and soul of this volume—the part that truly haunts you—is the second account by Count Philippe-Paul de Ségur.

The Story

De Ségur was a French nobleman who served on Napoleon's personal staff. His section focuses entirely on the 1812 invasion of Russia and the horrific retreat that followed. We see the Grand Army, confident and massive, march into Moscow, only to find a deserted, burning city. Then, the decision to turn back as winter closes in. What follows is not a military analysis, but a visceral, eyewitness chronicle of collapse. De Ségur describes the relentless cold that killed men mid-step, the scramble for scraps of food, the abandonment of the wounded, and the constant attacks by Cossack cavalry. He watches the breakdown of order and the transformation of a proud army into a desperate, shattered horde. It's the story of a retreat where nature itself was the greatest enemy.

Why You Should Read It

You should read this because it removes the myth and shows the raw human cost. History often remembers Napoleon as a genius and his campaigns as grand chess games. De Ségur pulls you into the mud and snow beside him. You feel the absurdity of officers in fine uniforms dying of hunger, and the tragedy of thousands vanishing in a Russian blizzard. His perspective is fascinating—he's loyal to Napoleon, yet he cannot hide the scale of the disaster. The book's power comes from its terrifying intimacy. It’s a masterclass in how a single, well-placed observer can capture the emotional truth of a historical event better than any textbook summary ever could.

Final Verdict

This is perfect for anyone who loves immersive history or classic war memoirs. If you enjoyed the personal feel of 'With the Old Breed' or the tragic scale of 'The Worst Journey in the World,' you'll appreciate de Ségur's account. It's also a great pick for Napoleon buffs who want to see the legend stripped bare by one of his own men. A word of caution: it’s not a light read. The suffering is relentless. But for a breathtaking, first-person journey into one of history's most famous military catastrophes, you can't get much closer than this.



🔖 Public Domain Notice

This digital edition is based on a public domain text. Distribute this work to help spread literacy.

Patricia Thomas
1 year ago

This digital copy caught my eye due to its reputation, the concise summaries at the end of each section are a lifesaver. A rare gem in a sea of mediocre content.

Matthew Harris
2 months ago

I've been looking for a reliable source on this topic, and the author’s unique perspective adds a fresh layer to the discussion. A mandatory read for anyone in this industry.

4
4 out of 5 (2 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *

Related eBooks